Skip to content
European Crisis TV
LiveEurope-wide LiveConfirmed

Russia demands Finland leave NATO as part of Ukraine peace terms, Helsinki says no

Bild and the New York Times reported wide-ranging Russian demands, including a Finland NATO exit and a pullback to 1997 lines; Helsinki called its demand non-negotiable.

Update ·

Kremlin spokesman Peskov directly denies Russia asked Finland to leave NATO, calling the claim untrue.

All 3 updates ↓
By ECTV Crisis DeskEditor-in-chief: Erik FerdinandPublished Updated 29 independent sources · 98% confidence

Also in:DeutschEestiMagyarLietuviųLatviešuNederlandsPolskiRomânăSlovenčinaУкраїнська

Location: Helsinki (town or village). Open the live Europe Crisis Map

Russia has demanded that Finland leave NATO and that the alliance remove its bases from the Baltic states as part of a proposed settlement to end the war in Ukraine, Germany's Bild newspaper reported on 13 November, citing a list of demands shared with European partners during talks in Abu Dhabi.

According to Bild, the plan also calls for recognition of Russian control over all of , a guarantee that Ukraine will never join NATO, the demilitarisation of Ukraine's Odesa and Mykolaiv ports, special legal status for the Russian language in Ukraine, and the division of Moldova into three parts, opening the door to referendums on independence for and Gagauzia.

The New York Times reported separately that it had seen a Russian document, dated 10 November and circulated at the Abu Dhabi talks, repeating demands Moscow first made in December 2021: withdrawal of NATO troops from countries that joined the alliance after 1997, including Poland and the Baltic states, a ban on further NATO enlargement, an end to all military activity across Ukraine, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus and Central Asia, an end to NATO's nuclear-sharing arrangements, and a bar on France and Britain using their own nuclear weapons to defend other European allies. The document would also halt Western military aid to Ukraine and let Kyiv join the EU only if it stayed outside the bloc's common defence policy.

In exchange, Russia is reportedly offering to withdraw nuclear weapons and intermediate-range missiles from Belarus and pull its troops out of Transnistria if Moldova commits to military neutrality. A separate proposal, reported by Romanian outlet G4Media via Russian state radio Ekho Moskvy, floats a "club" of five or six NATO states able to veto future membership bids, naming Ukraine, Moldova, Georgia and Armenia; a senior Russian foreign ministry official, Alexei Drobinin, has also raised bilateral non-aggression pacts with NATO's main members.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov made two separate comments on the demands. He said verbal Western assurances that NATO will not expand eastward are not enough and demanded this be put in writing, telling Russian state television Channel One that NATO had already expanded five or six times despite earlier promises. Separately, Peskov denied that Russia had asked Finland specifically to leave NATO, telling reporters "I know nothing about this... this was definitely not discussed," according to Interfax and Kyiv Post.

Finnish Defence Minister Antti Häkkänen rejected the Finland demand outright, calling it outrageous and saying Finland's NATO membership is not open to negotiation, according to Finnish broadcaster Yle. Foreign Minister Elina Valtonen said the decision on Finland's membership belongs to Finland and NATO alone. France's ambassador to Russia, Nicolas de Rivière, called Moscow's security demand legitimate while saying Ukraine also needs guarantees, according to an interview reported by Kyiv Post.

Moldova's government spokesman, Dumitru Ciorici, dismissed the reported demands concerning his country as scare tactics and provocations from Moscow, saying Chisinau remained focused on its EU-track reforms.

Russia's foreign ministry denied the Bild report through spokeswoman Maria Zakharova, according to ANSA. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, at the European Political Community summit in Dublin, said Europe does not need to negotiate a new security architecture with Russia because one already exists, and accused Moscow of undermining the 1975 Helsinki accords that let countries choose their own alliances. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney told the same summit that the security architecture of a free Europe would be decided by Europe and NATO, not by Russia.

Putin repeated his own position when he met US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner at the Kremlin on Thursday, two days after Russian, Ukrainian and US delegations held talks in Abu Dhabi. He said any foreign troops deployed in Ukraine after the war would be treated as legitimate military targets, rejected demilitarised grey zones between Russian and Ukrainian forces, and said the state border should be the only line of demarcation. The Institute for the Study of War said this reaffirms Moscow's demand for full control of Ukraine's Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions, including areas Russian forces have never captured. Kremlin aide Vladimir Medinsky said Russia would reject any territorial exchange and would keep expanding its security zone in Ukraine's Sumy and Kharkiv regions. Witkoff and Kushner travelled on to Dublin that evening for separate talks with Zelensky.

Follow this story

An email when there is a real update (a new toll, a cause, an arrest). Nothing else; stop with one click.

Free: one story at a time. Members follow as many stories as they like.

What we know

  • 2+ outlets · Adnkronos, Digi24 +3 Bild reported Russia's demands include Finland's exit from NATO, removal of NATO bases from the Baltic states, Russian control of all Donbas, demilitarising Odesa and Mykolaiv, and dividing Moldova into three parts.
  • 1 outlet · ANSA The New York Times reported a separate Russian document repeating Moscow's December 2021 demands, including a NATO pullback to 1997 lines and an end to Western military aid to Ukraine.
  • 1 outlet · Adnkronos Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov denied Russia specifically asked Finland to leave NATO, while separately demanding written NATO non-expansion guarantees.
  • 1 outlet · ANSA Moldova's government dismissed the reported demands about Moldova as Russian "scare tactics and provocations."
  • 2+ outlets · Adnkronos, ANSA Finland's ministers rejected the NATO-exit demand as non-negotiable; Russia's foreign ministry denied the wider Bild report through Maria Zakharova.
  • 1 outlet · ANSA Putin told US envoys any foreign troops in postwar Ukraine would be legitimate targets and rejected demilitarised zones; Kremlin aide Medinsky said Russia would keep expanding into Sumy and Kharkiv.

Not yet confirmed

  • Unconfirmed The full list of demands attributed to Russia has not been confirmed by Russian or European officials, and Russia's foreign ministry and the Kremlin have denied key elements of the Bild report.

How each fact is established: Verified checked by an ECTV editorOfficial stated by an official body2+ outlets reported independently by two or more news organisations1 outlet reported by a single news organisation so farUnconfirmed claimed or reportedHow we label facts

Why it matters for Europe

Finland shares a 1,340km border with Russia, and its NATO accession was one of the clearest shifts in European security since the invasion of Ukraine began. Many of the demands reported by Bild and the New York Times echo the draft treaties Russia published in December 2021, weeks before it invaded Ukraine, showing how far Moscow's opening positions in peace talks still reach beyond Ukraine itself, into NATO's size, deployments and nuclear arrangements across Europe. Russia's continued rejection of any demilitarised buffer zone and its insistence on full control of four partly-occupied Ukrainian regions, as flagged by the Institute for the Study of War, shows its battlefield demands have not softened even as the diplomatic process accelerates.

Live updates

  1. ·

    Kremlin spokesman Peskov directly denies Russia asked Finland to leave NATO, calling the claim untrue.

  2. ·

    A leaked Russian document reportedly revives Moscow's 2021 demand for NATO to return to 1997 borders, the NYT reports.

  3. ·

    The leaked Russian plan also reportedly covers demilitarising Ukraine's Odesa and Mykolaiv ports and a Black Sea navigation deal.

  4. First published.

Sources

Reported by 32 reports from 29 independent outlets in 8 countries.

Source balance

Premium

See how the 29 outlets behind this story spread from left to right, and which are official or OSINT sources.

Become a member →Log inHow we rate sources

Intelligence file

Premium

See how we verified this story

Confidence and impact scores, 28 more sources, the full situation report and the event timeline.

Questions and answers

What is Russia reportedly demanding over Finland and Ukraine?
According to Bild and the New York Times, Russia wants Finland out of NATO, Ukraine's Odesa and Mykolaiv ports demilitarised, and a NATO pullback to its 1997 positions, among other demands.
How did Finland and other governments respond?
Finland's ministers rejected the NATO-exit demand as non-negotiable, Moldova's government dismissed the Moldova-related demands as scare tactics, and the Kremlin itself denied ever asking Finland to leave NATO.
What is Russia's position on the battlefield itself?
Putin told US envoys that any foreign troops deployed in Ukraine after the war would be treated as legitimate military targets, and rejected proposals for demilitarised zones between Russian and Ukrainian forces.

This article was written with AI assistance from 33 verified reports and checked under the ECTV editorial policy. Spotted an error? Request a correction.

Share this story

finlandrussianatoukrainehelsinkisecuritymoldova